5 - Court and state


Learning objectives 
* To consider the different forms of art being created in different cities in the latter half of the 15th century, including Venice, Florence, Nuremburg and Rome 
* To consider the importance of drawing and printmaking to the spread of ideas and reputations during the period 


We are going to explore some of the different forms of painting and sculpture that were being produced in the second half of the fifteenth century. We shall look at the contrast between artists working in 

the Florentine tradition – which was particularly focused on drawing, ‘line’ and the realistic depiction of the human body – and 

the Venetian tradition, where colour and its emotional impact was much more important. 




In de vijftiende en zestiende eeuw bestaan er een aantal hoven in de Italië, onder andere dat van 
  • de Gonzaga’s in Mantua, 
  • de D’Estes in Ferrara 
  • de’ Medici in Florence.
  • de Montefeltre in Urbino

We’ll see how an artist like Andrea Mantegna, living and working in the north of Italy and closely associated with Venetian painters, would combine a fascination with the antique alongside elements of Florentine style to create a highly personal form of painting. 

We will look at the use of drawings in preparation for paintings and see how printmaking begins to spread information about works of art far beyond the cities and towns where pieces were made. We’ll consider the ways in which the careful study of the human body gave rise to new images of the body in action, with dramatic pictures of fighting men and complex compositions of twisted and writhing human forms becoming more popular. 

With the Papacy resurgent in Rome the city began to grow and develop as a state capital. Strong Popes began to encourage the Roman aristocracy (possibly ‘demand’ would be a better word) to help to beautify the city, building new palaces and widening roads. Unlike dynastic rulers in other states, a Pope had only a few years to make his mark on the city (and help his family to do likewise) before the next incumbent of the throne of St Peter would want to do the same, in their own way. Artists from across Italy were summoned to create decorations on the walls of the Sistine Chapel and in the private apartments of the Vatican, bringing new styles of painting right into the heart of the Papal States. In a similar way, the prestige of commissioning and collecting both modern and classical art gave patrons in smaller states an opportunity to use their passion for art and humanist learning to strengthen the prestige of their less powerful territories. 

As the young Albrecht Dürer brings the traditions of Southern Germany into prominence, we will also meet Tilman Riemenschneider, a sculptor who translated religious imagery into stunning works carved out of limewood, with the same concern for drama and emotional intensity as contemporary painters. His altarpieces are filled with the rich swirl of drapery and balletic movement, making carved wood seem as fragile and delicate as lace, but able to depict subtle emotions, towering strength and exquisite feeling.

1. Hartmann Schedel, A View of Rome, 1493. From the Liber Chronicarum or Nuremburg Chronicle 

2. Views of the Pantheon and the Palazzo Cancelleria, Rome 

3. The Gaddi Torso (possibly once owned by Ghiberti), 1st century BC. The Uffizi Gallery, Florence and The Belvedere Torso, 1st century BC. The Vatican Museums, Rome 

4. Lorenzo Ghiberti, detail of The Sacrifice of Isaac, 1401. Museo del Bargello, Florence 
← ←

5. View of the Chapel of Nicholas Vth, Vatican Palace, Rome 

6. Fra Angelico, detail from St Lawrence receives the treasures of the Church, 1447– 1450. Chapel of Nicholas Vth, Vatican Palace, Rome 

7. Donatello and Michelozzo, The Niche of the Parte Guelfa, 1423-25. Or San Michele, Florence 

8. Benozzo Gozzoli, The Horse Tamer, 1447–49. British Museum, London  → →


9. Antonio and Piero del Pollaiuolo, The Martyrdom of St Sebastian, 1475. National Gallery, London 
← ←

The muscular archers around Sebastian seem to be frozen in motion. They are arranged in pairs and have three basic poses, and are pivoted so that we see them from different angles; 
Antonio, who was a sculptor, might have made statuettes to use as models. He was, like Andrea Mantegna, intensely interested in anatomical exactness and in showing the human figure in dramatic, dynamic poses. 




10. Melozzo da Forli, Pope Sixtus IV endows the Vatican Library, 1477. Vatican Museums, Rome 

11. Sandro Botticelli, The Temptations of Christ, 1481–82. The Sistine Chapel, Rome 

12. Pietro Perugino, Christ Giving the Keys to Peter, 1480–82. The Sistine Chapel, Rome 

13. Pietro Perugino, Polyptych of the Certosa of Pavia, 1496–1500. National Gallery, London
De engelachtige figuren lijken sprekend op elkaar. Let ook op de vreemde houding van de nek.
De engelen in de lucht zijn waarschijnlijk een latere toevoeging, zij passen niet goed in de compositie.

14. Pinturicchio, The Resurrection, 1494. Borgia Apartments, Vatican Palace, Rome

"The Resurrection fresco by Pinturicchio, as has been argued in this paper, is a representation of the political interests of Alexander VI: the eastward expansion of Christianity by confronting the Muslims, and the conversion of the peoples found in the New World. The decoration of the Borgia Apartments was a visual manifestation of the Pope’s ambitions, which revolved around his own image and the legacy of his family. Based on our interpretation and historical analysis of a central detail of the Resurrection depicting a group of Amerindians, it is tempting to suggest that the fresco is a picture that holds together different elements typical of the years that followed Columbus’s “discovery”, years during which America was perceived as a territory full of contradictions, whose development would be characterized by fabulous and brutal stories produced by the encounter of two entirely different cultures. The erroneous perception of the New World as a part of Asia, and the European preconception, inspired by medieval text books, of foreign lands as inhabited by fabulous creatures who were altogether different from the people of Europe, the overwhelming influence of the Church and its projected evangelization of the New World, and Pinturicchio’s own artistic inventiveness, are all sources that feed into this detail of the Resurrection. Notably, these same elements would go on to play a considerable role in the ensuing development of the history of the Americas. In this sense, it may be said that the Resurrection fresco not only contains the first painted image of the New World, but also symbolizes the tensions and forces that were already at work from the very beginning of Europe’s understanding of America as an object of discovery and invention."
 
15. Pinturicchio, The Disputation of St Catherine of Alexandria, 1494. Borgia Apartments, Vatican Palace, Rome 

De Bellini schildersfamilie

De geschiedenis van de schildersfamilie van Bellini begint bij Jacopo Bellini. Er is weinig werk van hem bewaard gebleven. Het schilderij ‘Madonna en gezegend kind’ (1455) kun je bekijken in de Gallerie dell’Accademia. Van de zoons Gentile en Giovanni werd de laatste zeer bekend. Hij had grote invloed op de Venetiaanse schilderkunst en hij wordt wel de vader van de Venetiaanse schilderkunst genoemd. Zowel door materiaalgebruik (hij was een van de eersten die op de techniek van olieverf overging) als door techniek bracht hij een omslag in de schilderkunst teweeg. Giovanni Bellini wordt gezien als een grote meester van de vroege renaissance in Venetië.

Jacopo Bellini en zijn oudste zoon, Gentile Bellini, versierden de grote zaal van het dogepaleis. Zij legden vooral de grote feestelijkheden en praalstoeten van hun rijke stad op het doek vast.

De belangrijkste is de jongere zoon van Jacopo, Giovanni Bellini (circa 1432-1516). Giovanni Bellini wordt beschouwd als de stichter van de Venetiaanse schilderkunst c.q. de Venetiaanse school. Zijn schilderachtig werk staat in contrast met de tekenachtige stijl van de vroege renaissance en markeert een definitieve breuk met de gotiek.

De zachte en vloeiende penseelvoering is door vele generaties Venetiaanse schilders overgenomen. Het warme licht en de overtuigende weergave van atmosfeer loopt eveneens vooruit op recentere kunstwerken uit de Venetiaanse school.

Bellini wordt vooral bewonderd omdat hij als één van de eerste op een overtuigende wijze atmosfeer kon suggereren.

Andrea Mantegna (1431, Padua)
Mantegna and Bellini were very different artists but they had a close family connection. In 1453, Mantegna married Bellini’s sister, Nicolosia. For some years, they worked closely together. They went their separate ways, but they never forgot each other. When Mantegna died, it was Bellini who finished his final commission.



16. Mantegna; Camera degli Sposi, Mantua 

17. Andrea Mantegna, The Martyrdom of St Sebastian, c.1480. Musée du Louvre, Paris 

18. Andrea Mantegna, Virgin and Child with Two Saints, 1490–1505. National Gallery, London 

19. Andrea Mantegna, The Madonna della Vittoria, 1496. Musée du Louvre, Paris

20. Giovanni Bellini, The Agony in the Garden, 1458–60. National Gallery, London 

21. Andrea Mantegna, The Agony in the Garden, 1455–56. National Gallery, London 

22. Jacopo Bellini, St John the Baptist Preaching, 1440–50. Musée du Louvre, Paris 

23. Jacopo Bellini, The Flagellation of Christ, c.1450. Musée du Louvre, Paris 

24. Gentile Bellini, A Procession in St Mark’s Square, 1496. Galleria dell’ Accademia, Venice 



25. Giovanni Bellini, Madonna and Child with Saints, 1488. Santa Maria Gloriosa dei Frari, Venice 
Detail → → →

26. Giovanni Bellini, Madonna and Child with Two Saints, c.1490. Galleria dell’ Accademia, Venice 

27. Pisanello, The Vision of St Eustace, 1440. National Gallery, London 

28. Pisanello, Drawings of a Horse and a European Bee-eater from the Codex Vallardi, mid-15th century. Musée du Louvre, Paris

29. Pisanello, Four Studies of a Female Nude, an Annunciation and Two Women Swimming, c.1425. Museum Boymans van Beuningen, Rotterdam 

30. Raphael, Red Chalk studies for the Alba Madonna, c.1510. Palais des Beaux-Arts, Lille


31. Unknown Master, The Buxheim St Christopher, 1423. John Rylands Library, University of Manchester 
← ←

One of the earliest dated examples
of German wood-block printing

32. Antonio del Pollaiuolo, Battle of Ten Nude Men, 1470–75. National Museum, Budapest 

33. Andrea Mantegna, The Descent of Christ into Limbo, 1492. Barbara Piasecka Johnson Foundation, Princeton 

34. Andrea Mantegna, The Triumphs of Caesar – Bearers of Trophies and Bullion, 1484– late 1490s. The Royal Collection, Hampton Court Palace, London 

35. After Andrea Mantegna, Engraving of The Triumphs of Caesar, 1599. Art Institute of Chicago, Illinois 

37. (l) Martin Schongauer, The Nativity, (engraving), 1470. National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C.
36.(r) Martin Schongauer, The Nativity, 1480. Staatliche Museen, Berlin  

38. Martin Schongauer, The Virgin Annunciate, 1485–90. National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C. 

39. Veit Stoss, The Virgin and Child, 1495. Victoria and Albert Museum, London 

40. Albrecht Durer, St Jerome in a Landscape, 1496. National Gallery, London 

41. Albrecht Durer, St Jerome in a Landscape, (engraving) 1496. Art Gallery of New South Wales, Sydney 

42. Michael Pacher, Altarpiece of the Church Fathers, 1483. Alte Pinakothek, Munich 

43. Michael Pacher, The St Wolfgang’s Altarpiece, 1479–81. Paris Church, St Wolfgang, Austria 

44. Tilman Riemenschneider, The Heilige-Blut Altar, 1501–02. St Jakobskirche, Rothenburg ob der Tauber 




45. Tilman Riemenschneider, Two Mourning Women, c.1508. Landesmuseum, Wurttemburg, Stuttgart 
→ →

46. Donatello, St Mary Magdalene, c.1457. Museo del Opera del Duomo, Florence